You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
From the 2026-08-20 conformance review. Neither item is guest-reachable — both concern the fault vocabulary at the embedder (host-input) boundary. Grouped because the fix discipline is shared: host misuse should fail loudly with a host-error vocabulary, never silently and never with internal AssertionErrors.
1. Missing record/flags labels from embedder values lower silently
runtime/src/cabi/store.ts ~257-268 (packFlagsIntoInt) and ~210 (storeRecord), runtime/src/cabi/lower.ts ~140 (lowerFlatRecord) vs definitions.py:1782-1786/1808-1814: the reference raises KeyError (host-precondition failure) when a record/flags value lacks a label; deltic's v[l] ? 1 : 0 treats a missing flag as unset — a silent wrong answer — and record lowering passes undefined downstream to fail later (or, for bool fields, silently store false via truthiness).
Suggested: a loud typed host error (TypeError-class, matching e.g. HostBuffer's misuse errors) on missing labels at the lowering boundary.
2. Multi-store lift failures escape as AssertionError inside a guest activation
runtime/src/cabi/async_values.ts ~108-126: liftAsyncValue can throw an internal assert_ when a shared stream/future object bound to another Store is passed in (host misuse: multi-copy/multi-store plumbing). The failure surfaces inside a guest's lift as a non-Trap, non-host-error throw — a different fault vocabulary from every other guest-reachable failure on that path. Same class: lowerStream/lowerFuture element-mismatch asserts (~166-199), host-boundary-only in practice since guest↔guest transfer routes through FACT's trapIf checks.
Suggested: classify these as host errors (the cross-copy refusal machinery in embedder/copy.ts is the existing precedent for loud, named multi-copy diagnostics).
Classification from the review: B (undocumented divergences at the host boundary), high confidence on the differences, medium on urgency.
Activity